Is Anthony Mackie the MCU's Permanent Captain America?

The persistent rumors of Chris Evans' return as Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) stem from the cyclical nature of comic book deaths and rebirths. In comics, Steve Rogers has repeatedly died and been resurrected, with other characters temporarily taking up the Captain America mantle – Bucky Barnes and Sam Wilson. This pattern fuels speculation about Evans' potential return.

However, Anthony Mackie, as Sam Wilson, the current Captain America, asserts his hope to retain the role, acknowledging its dependence on the success of Captain America: Brave New World. He believes the film will solidify Sam Wilson as Captain America.

Mackie's position seems more secure than Sebastian Stan's (Bucky Barnes) ever was in the comics, where Steve Rogers eventually returned, leading to a shared Captain America mantle between Steve and Sam.

The MCU, unlike the comics, prioritizes permanence in its storytelling. Deaths tend to be final, unlike the resurrections common in comics. This suggests Steve Rogers' retirement is likely permanent.

Nate Moore, an MCU producer, confirms that Sam Wilson is the definitive MCU Captain America, emphasizing the character's distinct identity from Steve Rogers. Julius Onah, director of Captain America: Brave New World, highlights the dramatic potential of Sam Wilson's leadership role within the MCU and his future leadership of the Avengers.

The MCU's commitment to permanent change distinguishes it from the comics, creating higher stakes and a unique narrative approach. Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson is established as the current and likely enduring Captain America, leading the Avengers into a new era. The future of the Avengers will be significantly shaped by his leadership.